Can a Trustee Do Their Own Accounting?

Nothing generally prevents a trustee from preparing their own accounting. The duty to account runs to the trustee, not to any particular preparer, and a trustee who produces a complete and accurate accounting has discharged it regardless of who did the arithmetic. The real question is not permission but exposure: a trustee is personally answerable for what the accounting says, and that liability does not diminish because the accounting was prepared in good faith by someone doing it for the first time.

Why fiduciary accounting is not ordinary accounting

Fiduciary accounting differs greatly from both tax accounting and financial accounting. It is not a profit-and-loss statement and not a net-worth statement. It reports what the fiduciary did with the property, with charges and credits, receipts and disbursements, and principal and income kept separate, in a format courts and beneficiaries expect to see.

A trustee who is a competent bookkeeper, or even a general-practice CPA, may produce a document that is arithmetically correct and still not a fiduciary accounting. The errors that matter are structural: assets reported at market value rather than carry value, principal and income commingled, schedules that do not reconcile to each other, a format the court will not accept.

Where self-preparation is reasonable

A single-beneficiary trust, held for a short period, invested in one or two accounts, with no real property, no closely held interests and no distributions beyond the routine, is a manageable accounting. If the trustee is the sole beneficiary’s parent and no one is going to object, the stakes are correspondingly low.

The common thread is simplicity plus the absence of competing interests. Where nobody is disadvantaged by an allocation error, the error is correctable rather than consequential.

Where it stops being reasonable

Multiple beneficiary classes with competing interests. An income beneficiary and a remainderman are in structural tension, and every allocation decision moves money between them. This is the single clearest indicator that preparation should not be casual.

Any sign a beneficiary is dissatisfied. Once an objection is foreseeable, the accounting is a litigation document and should be prepared as one.

Assets that require judgment: closely held entities, real property, oil and gas, loans to beneficiaries, anything where a receipt must be characterized rather than simply recorded.

A multi-year backlog, where periods have to tie to each other and an early error propagates through everything after it.

A court filing requirement, where the format is prescribed and a non-conforming accounting will be rejected.

The attorney question

Trustees often assume the estate’s attorney will prepare the accounting. Some do. Many do not, and many who do are supervising a paralegal rather than performing the analysis themselves.

Attorneys and accountants are doing different work here. Counsel advises on duties, exposure and procedure, and litigates objections. The accounting itself is an accounting exercise: tracing, classification, reconciliation and presentation. Firms and fiduciaries that rely on generalists or non-accounting professionals for this work sometimes learn hard lessons in contested matters, which is a pattern visible from the forensic side of the practice.

The practical approach is to ask counsel directly whether preparation is within their engagement, and if so, who performs it.

What the trustee remains responsible for

Engaging a preparer does not transfer the duty. The trustee still signs, still certifies, and is still the party a court surcharges. What outside preparation buys is not transferred liability but a document more likely to withstand examination, prepared by someone who has seen the failure modes before.

How T.E.A. Fiduciary helps

We specialize exclusively in fiduciary accounting and act as a partner to law firms, trustees and other fiduciaries, as well as to beneficiaries. We prepare accountings to court-conformed standards in all states, and we work alongside counsel rather than in place of them. Where the matter is contested, we prepare accountings for petition and litigation and perform forensic analysis of financial records, investment strategy, income and principal treatment, fees, related-party issues and valuation.

Whether a trustee must account at all, and in what form, is governed by state law. See fiduciary accounting requirements by state.

General information, not legal or tax advice.

More: our services · state requirements · contact us

Written by Christina Gutman, C.P.A. — Founder and Principal of T.E.A. Fiduciary. Christina is licensed as a Certified Public Accountant by the State of California and has specialized exclusively in fiduciary accounting for over a decade, preparing trust, estate, and conservatorship accountings for law firms, professional fiduciaries, trust companies, family offices, and individual trustees nationwide. She has also served as a forensic consultant in contested accounting matters. More about Christina